our reviews


“Candace and Michael are first class. Our first experience with a B&B and definitely will be back. Beautiful house and really makes you feel at home. We will definitely recommend this to all of our friends and we will be back. Breakfast was amazing.”

- Julee and Tim, Mesa AZ


“Thank you for the wonderful conversation, yummy breakfast and comfy bed!”

- Lee, Laura, Olivia & Will, Tucson AZ


"Great hosts - warm & friendly, who know and love Jerome. Comfortable bed and set of rooms, wonderful snacks and breakfast. Once oriented, it was an easy (if vertical) walk up to Main Street. Very friendly dogs and kitty. Loved all the art and decor - it felt like I was in a gallery.”

- Anna and D.J., Boulder CO


“Thank you so much for the wonderful stay in Jerome! Candace and Michael were such wonderful and welcoming hosts and immediately made us feel at home. The home is so unique and filled with wonder, and your animals were such a treat! Thank you for “shuttling” us into town for dinner and to experience live music at The Spirit Room - really going the extra mile! Breakfast was lovely and our only regret is not getting to stay over another night! Thanks so much.”

- Ken and Kendra, Calgary AB, Canada


“What a delight The Wary Buffalo is! Certainly our lives have been made richer by meeting you Candace, Michael, O’Keeffe, Teddy and Mo Cuishle. Thank you for all your kindness and inspiration! Until we meet again …”

- Lisa and Doug, Sunland CA


”Candace and Mike were wonderful hosts! The space was very private with a comfy bed and the location right below town couldn't be better. We felt so welcome and they cooked us a delicious breakfast! We'll definitely stay again next time we visit Jerome."

- Kellen and Sam


“Candace and Mike considered every detail to make our stay comfortable. From the tea set up to the incredible breakfast, it ended up being the perfect place. The house is just a quick walk down the hill from town and if you're not in a walking mood or don't like the dark, they were kind enough to offer to shuttle us too. They do have pets, so if you're allergic, you might run into some trouble, but if you're animal lovers like us, it makes the stay even more charming!"

- Kim and Bucky

The Wary Buffalo 2015